Welcome to Castaway's on the Island
Nestled at 131 Clinton St in La Crosse, WI, Castaway's on the Island offers a delightful escape for food lovers. Guests rave about the casual, welcoming atmosphere, complemented by stunning views of the river teeming with seagulls and bald eagles. The menu showcases seasonal dishes like herb-crusted walleye and flavorful risotto, all beautifully presented and expertly seasoned. Renowned for attentive service, staff members engage with diners, ensuring a memorable experience. The blend of exquisite flavors and attention to detail makes Castaway's a new favorite among locals, promising delightful meals in a picturesque setting.
Castaway's on the Island: Reviews & Ratings
Atmosphere is casual, comfortable, food was fantastic, we had salmon,risotto,Brussel sprouts...encrusted walleye with a blanc wine sauce with rice pilaf& asparagus. Everything was done very well, so well seasoned & presented. Really impressed. View out the big windows behind bar while we ate was hundreds of seagulls & bald eagles flying over river it was a beautiful view while we ate.
Beautiful scenery, great atmosphere, welcoming staff and great tasting food... All of those can be found at Castaways on the Island! Our waiter was very engaging and quite resourceful when asked for recommendations on drinks and items on the menu! He helped us match our drinks to our likes so we could try something new. As our meals started to come to the table he was sure to check in and be sure we had all that we needed. Even the cook came out to check on our meals and be sure all was well. My mahi mahi and risotto was wonderful, it was fresh and full of flavor! We will defiantly be going back again!! Thank you for a GREAT girls night out!
Wow! This is a Great place. We've been coming here a lot lately. The food and service are excellent. I also enjoy the really nice views of the water.
10/10 our new favorite restaurant in La Crosse! Bartender Patrick is super attentive and kind and made great recommendations, I went with the herb crusted Walleye which was their special for the night, super yummy sauce under the wild rice. My husband went for the clam chowder and the filet mignon. His steak was better than any steak we’ve had downtown. Chef came out and asked how everything was and thanked us for coming. Very homey and friendly with a great view. The salad plate was cold to the touch and the dinner plate was hot kept everything nice and steamy. Just a ton of attention to detail and it made it such a great experience. I’m telling everybody rock on guys!!!!
Back for my second time. Been a big fine dining guy my whole life. Always frequented waterfront and freight house when in La crosse. This blows everything around out of the water. Price, portioning, flavor etc, Go to spot now Edit, ordered carry out and it wasn’t good at all. Will try again in person
This restaurant is a MUST see and experience! The staff is incredible along with the amazing food. Went with friends and we had such a great time! Pat provided excellent service, the owner made sure we had a wonderful time and the chef even made an appearance to see how everything was! They have a great menu and full bar with a beautiful view. Put it in your list to visit when you can!
Upon walking into Castaways on French Island WI you immediately feel like you are family. Alea as the hostess greeted us as we walked in and Pat the bartender and sever immediately asked how we were doing and said we have an amazing treat in store for you. We settle on wine, a ceaser salad and the special of the day for dinner. The special being slice whole roasted beef shoulder filet with malt red wine gas-trek sauce with asparagus and mushroom risotto. What an amazing and mouthwatering delight this was. Chef Taite came and checked on us with the enthusiasm that only comes with someone that has a passion for what he does. Dessert was a hazelnut creme brulee. All I can say is the owner Dan and all his staff deserve in the world of hockey what would be considered a hat trick! Ambiance, staff, and really family made this a must to keep coming back to.
This was the perfect spot to have dinner with friends while enjoying the great atmosphere on the river. Our waiter was fun and intuitive. I ordered the scallops and they were cooked to perfection. The chef came out to check on us, which I thought was very cool. To round out the meal, we shared a delicious chocolate lava cake with ice cream. A good time was had by all. I will definitely dine there again!
Location
-
131 Clinton St, La Crosse, WI 54603, United States Hotline: +1 608-519-9700
Welcome to Castaway's on the Island, a culinary gem nestled at 131 Clinton St, La Crosse, WI. A destination for food enthusiasts, this restaurant beautifully marries a laid-back atmosphere with exquisite dining experiences. Imagine cozying up in a charming setting, with the gentle hum of the river and panoramic views enhanced by the presence of seagulls and majestic bald eagles.
Every visitor is greeted with a warm welcome, ensuring that the service matches the quality of the food. The staff go above and beyond, as noted by Leigh Flynn, whose waiter expertly recommended drinks tailored to personal tastes, enhancing the dining adventure. This level of attentiveness sets a standard for what a great dining experience should feel like.
The dishes at Castaway's are crafted with passion and precision. From herb-crusted walleye to succulent filet mignon accompanied by velvety clam chowder, each plate is a testament to the skill of the kitchen. Customer reviews frequently highlight the freshness and robust flavors of the meals. For example, Leslie Boehlke raved about the encrusted walleye served with a blanc wine sauce, while Alexis Daubner, effusing enthusiasm, noted how attention to detail in meal presentation made her experience special. It’s clear the chef not only aims to please the palate but also to create a visual feast.
The atmosphere is equally captivating—casual yet sophisticated, making it an ideal spot for any occasion, be it a girls' night out or a romantic dinner. The waterfront views create a serene backdrop, as emphasized by Glenn Sadowski, who appreciates the scenic setting as much as he does the delightful dishes.
With an impressive menu and a commitment to stellar service, it’s no wonder why Castaway's on the Island has quickly become a favorite among locals. Whether you are a fine dining connoisseur or simply looking for a cozy dinner spot, this culinary destination promises not just a meal but a memorable experience worth savoring. So come, escape to the island—for an evening where flavor and atmosphere meet in perfect harmony.